How to Talk Commission With a Real Estate Agent (Without Burning Bridges)
If you’ve ever thought, “How do I negotiate commission with a real estate agent?” you’re asking the right question. Real estate commissions can represent thousands, sometimes tens of thousands of dollars, depending on your property’s price. With such a large expense, it makes sense to ask whether there’s room to adjust.
The answer: yes, commissions are negotiable. They’re not fixed by law, and agents know that clients will sometimes push back. The key is to negotiate respectfully. You want to save money, but you also want your agent to feel motivated to represent you. Cutting too deep or negotiating too aggressively can backfire if it damages the partnership.
This guide will walk you through everything you need to know: how commissions work, when you have leverage, practical negotiation strategies, and alternative fee models to consider. By the end, you’ll feel equipped to have this conversation confidently without burning bridges.
Know the Shifting Rules of the Game
For decades, the commission system seemed almost untouchable. In Canada and the U.S., it was customary for sellers to pay 5–6% of the sale price, which was split between the seller’s agent and the buyer’s agent. Buyers rarely thought about commission at all.
But the real estate landscape is changing. Following lawsuits and regulatory shifts, particularly in the U.S., there is now far more transparency around commission. In many markets:
- Buyer’s agents must now sign written agreements with clients before showing homes.
- Sellers are no longer automatically expected to cover buyer-agent commissions.
- Commission offers can no longer be “baked in” quietly to MLS listings; they have to be disclosed upfront.
What this means for you: discussing commission is no longer taboo. Agents expect you to ask, and in many cases, they’re prepared to explain their value and adjust where possible.
Do Your Homework: Know the Market Norms
Walking into a negotiation without knowing the going rate is like stepping into a poker game without knowing the rules. To negotiate successfully, you first need to understand what’s “normal” in your area.
- National averages: In North America, total commissions usually range between 4% and 6% of the sale price.
- Regional variation: In high-demand urban areas, rates may be slightly lower (closer to 4–5%), while in rural or slower-moving markets, 6% is more common.
- Agent splits: Remember, the commission you pay is often split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. So when you negotiate, you’re affecting not just one professional but potentially two.
You can gather data by:
- Interviewing several agents and directly asking about their rates.
- Checking local real estate forums or community groups.
- Talking to friends, neighbors, or colleagues who have recently bought or sold.
If you discover that most agents in Streetsville, for example, charge 5%, you’ll be in a better position to ask for 4.5% without seeming unreasonable.
Understand Your Leverage
Not all homes and not all clients have equal negotiating power. Here are factors that give you more leverage when asking for a reduced commission:
- High-priced homes
Selling a million-dollar property is very different from selling a $250,000 condo. Even a slightly lower percentage commission can still yield the agent a healthy paycheck. - Desirable listings
If your home is in a hot neighborhood, in excellent condition, or priced attractively, it may practically sell itself. Agents know these properties require less effort, so they may be more flexible on rates. - Bundled deals
If you’re planning to sell your current home and buy your next one with the same agent, you have bargaining power. They’ll be earning two commissions from you, which justifies a discount. - Slow markets
In markets where sales are sluggish, agents may accept a lower fee rather than risk losing your listing to a competitor. - Prepared sellers
If you’ve already done some of the heavy lifting, like staging, professional photography, or marketing, your agent may agree that less work justifies a reduced fee.
The important takeaway: be ready to explain why your situation justifies flexibility.
Communicate With Tact and Clarity
Negotiating commission isn’t about cornering your agent; it’s about having a respectful, business-minded conversation. Here’s how to approach it:
- Start on a positive note: “I appreciate your experience, and I’d really like to work with you. Could we talk about your commission structure?”
- Anchor with facts: “I’ve researched the market, and it looks like 5% is the norm here. Would you consider 4.5% given my home’s location and condition?”
- Focus on collaboration: Frame it as finding a fair balance rather than cutting costs at their expense.
- Clarify expectations: Ask directly what services are included. If they agree to a lower commission, confirm that you’ll still get full marketing, open houses, and support.
- Stay flexible: If the agent can’t reduce their percentage, ask if they’ll add extra value instead. That could mean covering staging costs, providing premium online ads, or including professional videography.
Approaching the conversation with curiosity rather than confrontation keeps the relationship intact.
Know the Right Timing
When you ask is almost as important as how you ask.
- Before signing any agreement: Commission should be discussed upfront, before signing a listing contract or buyer’s representation agreement. Once you sign, the terms are locked in.
- Before the busy season: In spring and early summer, when the market is hot, agents may be less flexible. In slower months, they’re often more willing to negotiate.
- Before they’ve invested: Once an agent has already paid for marketing or photography, they’ll be less inclined to adjust fees.
Think of it like buying a car; you’ll get the best deal before paperwork is finalized, not after you’ve already driven off the lot.
Understand Alternative Commission Models
Traditional percentage-based commissions aren’t the only game in town. Depending on your needs, you might explore:
- Flat-fee listings: Pay a set fee to list your home on the MLS. You handle showings, negotiations, and paperwork. This works best for sellers comfortable with a DIY approach.
- Discount brokerages: Some brokerages advertise lower rates (like 1–2%) by streamlining services or offering fewer frills. They’re cheaper, but you may sacrifice personalized attention.
- Tiered commissions: You agree to a standard rate if the home sells at or above the asking price, but a reduced rate if it sells below. This incentivizes the agent to push for top value.
- Buyer rebates: In some markets, buyer’s agents may rebate part of their commission to you at closing. This is becoming more common as commissions face scrutiny.
Exploring these models doesn’t mean you’ll always pick them, but knowing your options strengthens your negotiating position.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
When negotiating commission, many clients stumble by making these mistakes:
- Waiting too long: If you try to renegotiate after signing a contract, you’ll lose leverage.
- Being overly aggressive: Treating it like a battle can sour the relationship with your agent.
- Focusing only on cost: The cheapest agent isn’t always the best agent. If a lower commission comes with fewer services, you may end up losing money in the long run.
- Ignoring buyer’s agents: If your listing commission is too low, buyer’s agents may hesitate to show your property because they won’t be fairly compensated.
Avoiding these pitfalls ensures your negotiation is productive instead of counterproductive.
Final Checklist for Negotiating Commission
Here’s a quick recap of the key steps to follow:
- Research average commission rates in your area.
- Identify what leverage you have high-value home, a slow market, a bundle deal, etc.
- Bring up the topic early, before signing anything.
- Be polite and respectful in your approach.
- Offer a specific number or model instead of vague requests.
- Confirm what services you’ll receive if the rate is reduced.
- Stay open to alternative compensation models.
- Get everything in writing once an agreement is reached.
Commission as a Partnership
Commission negotiation doesn’t have to feel awkward or confrontational. At its heart, it’s about creating a partnership that works for both sides. You want to pay a fair price for services, and your agent wants to be fairly compensated for their expertise and effort.
By coming prepared with research, understanding your leverage, and approaching the conversation with respect, you can often save money while still keeping your agent motivated to do their best work.
Selling in Streetsville or the Surrounds?
If you’re preparing to buy or sell in Streetsville, Mississauga, you don’t need to feel awkward about commission conversations. Work with a professional who values transparency, flexibility, and results.
Mississauga Homes’ Real Estate Agent Streetsville understands that every client is unique. They’ll walk you through commission options clearly, help you structure a fair agreement, and then focus on what really matters: getting your home sold or helping you buy the right one.
Contact Mississauga Homes’ Streetsville Agent today to discuss your goals and build a commission arrangement that feels fair, respectful, and effective.
Follow our social media pages below:
Find out more articles that can help you below:
What Is Average Realtor Commission
